| 1955-
Norwalk 19 Tiffin 0 |
1980-
Norwalk 20 Tiffin 14 |
| 1956- Tiffin
25 Norwalk 13 |
1981- Tiffin
7 Norwalk 3 |
| 1957- Tiffin
20 Norwalk 6 |
1982- Tiffin
36 Norwalk 0 |
| 1958- Tiffin
41 Norwalk 18 |
1983- Tiffin
17 Norwalk 13 |
| 1959- Tiffin
12 Norwalk 6 |
1984- Tiffin
21 Norwalk 12 |
| 1960-
Norwalk 24 Tiffin 14 |
1985- Tiffin
28 Norwalk 12 |
| 1961- Tiffin
14 Norwalk 8 |
1986- Tiffin
27 Norwalk 8 |
| 1962- Tiffin
34 Norwalk 14 |
1987- Tiffin
22 Norwalk 7 |
| 1963-
Norwalk 12 Tiffin 12 |
1988- Tiffin
46 Norwalk 6 |
| 1964- Tiffin
20 Norwalk 8 |
1989- Tiffin
37 Norwalk 0 |
| 1965-
Norwalk 8 Tiffin 6 |
1990- Tiffin
20 Norwalk 6 |
| 1966-
Norwalk 12 Tiffin 2 |
1991- Tiffin
33 Norwalk 16 |
| 1967- Tiffin
6 Norwalk 0 |
1992-
Norwalk 19 Tiffin 17 |
| 1968- Tiffin
6 Norwalk 0 |
1993- Tiffin
23 Norwalk 0
|
| 1969- Tiffin
26 Norwalk 15 |
1994- Tiffin
13 Norwalk 0 |
| 1970- Tiffin
41 Norwalk 0 |
1995- Tiffin
54 Norwalk 0 |
| 1971- Tiffin
30 Norwalk 0 |
1996- Tiffin
56 Norwalk 0 |
| 1972- Tiffin
20 Norwalk 0 |
1997- Tiffin
46 Norwalk 3 |
| 1973-
Norwalk 12 Tiffin 7 |
1998- Tiffin
21 Norwalk 14 |
| 1974-
Norwalk 24 Tiffin 0 |
1999- Tiffin
56 Norwalk 7 |
| 1975- Tiffin
14 Norwalk 6 |
2000- Tiffin
55 Norwalk 7 |
| 1976-
Norwalk 6 Tiffin 0 |
2001- Tiffin
75 Norwalk 7 |
| 1977-
Norwalk 24 Tiffin 12 |
2002- Tiffin
41 Norwalk 7 |
| 1978- Tiffin
34 Norwalk 22 |
2003- Tiffin
53 Norwalk 6 |
| 1979- Tiffin
20 Norwalk 0 |
2004- Tiffin 45 Norwalk 7 |